Jerusalem Magazine is edited by Larry Price.: "This electronic work is protected by a Creative Commons non-commercial, full attribution, non-distribution license."
Mr. Price's documentary "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers" is available at amazon.com."The Rebbe & The German Officer, and "Rescue Train" are available upon request or VOD at www.pricecominc.com. Novels "Arrested Overnight" and "Sambatyon Crossing" are available on Kindle.
Jerusalem Magazine is edited by Larry Price, a veteran filmmaker and journalist based in Jerusalem.
See also "www.pricecominc.com or www.jerusalemmagazine.com
see video http://www.youtube.com/v=VVH79iYELpE or type in pricecom at search bar.
Amazing. According to a poll conducted by Israeli pollsters 74% of the Israeli people think temporary Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did a good job handing the COVID-19. In fact, it was a few people in the Health Ministry who fought with their incompetent Minister and demanded the closing of schools, restaurants, and synagogues. According to media reports,
Some analysts say that scare tactics kept people indoors and paranoid about some microbe killing them. Others point out that the population was loaded up with such fear that those in charge were the ones you had to trust (Trump excluded). At least in Israel. And that savior, say some critics, was Netanyahu. Now, these critics point out, if Netanyahu isn't supported, the world may come to an end.
While Israel is coming out of the lockdown, and life returning to normal, with masks and social distancing, that isn't to say that a second wave, perhaps much deadlier, of COVID-19 won't come back in the fall, according to health officials in the USA. In fact, the US health agencies are preparing for just such an eventuality. This time, if the virus hits, they'll be ready. Netanyahu won't be leading the fight worldwide. But, say his critics, he may take credit for it.
Veteran observers say that former Prime Minister, and war hero, Ariel Sharon pulled something similar when he initiated the withdrawal from Gaza.He was nearly under indictment for the Greek Island Affair (his son took the fall instead and went to jail).
However, say these observers, while this withdrawal was going on and the country on the verge of war the question arose, "Which judge has the courage to indict Sharon when he is the warrior needed to defend the country." And indeed, these observers say, Sharon was never indicted.
Sharon was, in the opinion of some, the tutor and role model for disgraced former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who was jailed for bribery, and Netanyahui on how to steal and get away with it. Olmert wasn't as good a student, say the pundits, as Netanyahu.
Back in the day, when Ehud Barak ran a campaign for PM called "Tzav Shmoneh" (the call up notice reserve soldiers get during a war ordering them to their units). Again, scare tactics. Now, say the pundits, here's Netanyahu who goes to trial on May 24th after having avoided any interference by the High Court, even when he engineered a change in the basic law, essentially allowing two Prime Ministers under a questionable rotation deal that should have been struck down, sailing into his fifth term as prime minister."A shandah," cry his critics.
Others compare what's happening with Lt. Gen Michael Flynn, who confessed to lying to the FBI twice, and is now free of any charges, to Netanyahu to perhaps discern what he has in mind. Netanyahu, say his critics, has postured that he is so essential to the well-being of Israel, if not the world, that the courts should either dismiss the charges against him, or look so favorably upon him that he is judged innocent, or atleast not guilty, of any of the indictments against him.Sharon did it, say the sages. Flynn did it with help from the Donald.Bibi will probably do it, with help from, of all people Gantz.What a world, they moan.
Others question the inefficiency and unpreparedness of the Health Ministry when faced with the epidemic. Analysts say that the Health Ministry was the neglected child for years.Monies that should have gone to hospitals and medical facilities were drained from what should have been the Health Ministry's budget and given to favorite sons, settlements, ultra-orthodox day schools and yeshivot, roads to nowhere, who kept the coalition afloat.
Social Welfare budgets were also drained before they were even submitted. One jokester asked if the public remembered the song, "Where have all the flowers gone?...."Now says the jokester, the lyrics are "Where has all the money gone?"And who was the PM during these financial shenanigans?
"Need I say?" asks the jokester. "Well I will. It was Netanyahu. Twenty years of neglect. And a microbe erases all the misdeeds.The microbe that now will end humanity. Go Figure."
The Los Alamos National Laboratory, according to the Washington Post,
has found mutations of the COVID-19 that are apparently more contagious
than the original. These mutations are spreading around the world. The
laboratory wants to warn researchers that these mutations should be
considered when working on a vaccine or by the time the vaccine is on
the market it will not be effective.
These mutations apparently replicate faster than the original. One,
called D614G has different spikes than those seen in the original
coronavirus strain. The lab speculates that one strain hit the west
coast and a mutation the east coast of the USA. These mutations are not
surprising, said Dr. Peter Pitts, but it does increase the urgency to
protect the public through social isolation and other means.
Meanwhile, Pfizer pharmaceuticals has begun human testing multiple
versions of an experimental vaccine this week, starting on ages 18-55
and moving to over 85 if the tests prove effective and safe.
While in Israel, according to Israel’s Channel 11 news, the National
Emergency Authority has issued a forecast that a second wave of
infections may hit around the time of the Jewish New Year. The authority
called on the government to use this period to prepare hospitals for a
substantial increase in respiratory ventilation treatment capacity.
And Israel’s Health Ministry director general said yesterday that HMO
clinics will begin serological (blood) tests of 100,000 citizens to see
how widely the virus has spread across the country and how susceptible
the population is to a new wave of infections.
Israel is slowly opening up the schools. Next week the pre-schools
are scheduled to open followed by other grades. However, Marco Jelli, a
mathematical epidemiologist from Trento, Italy said closing schools
reduces the surge of the virus by 40% -60% and slows the epidemic. Tests
have shown that children who test positive have just as much of the
virus as adults and are just as infectious.
Dr. Christian Drostan, a virologist in Berlin, tested 60,000 people
for COVID-19 and said, “I’m a bit reluctant to happily recommend to
politicians that we can now reopen day cares and schools.” However, Dr.
Jennifer Nozzo, an epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins, said, “I do worry at
some point the accumulated harm from the measures may exceed the harm
to the kids from the virus.” She inferred the schools could not be
closed for long.
Experts all agree that students should be scheduled to come to school
at different times, reduce the number of students in the building at
any one time, desks should be at least 2 meters apart, with separation
shields if possible. Large gatherings of students should be avoided.
So far, restrictions have mostly been lifted in Israel. Israel has
essentially emerged from quarantine. Malls and outdoor markets have
reopened. Restaurants are still awaiting the ok. Masks and social
distancing are still required when outside. Groups are limited to 20
except for a wedding where the number rises to 50. Preschool begins on
Sunday. Grades above four are still waiting to hear when their school
can begin. Children and grandchildren can visit parents and
grandparents. Although hugging and kissing are not recommended.
Prof. Yehuda Carmeli, an epidemiologist, said that “We are at a
dangerous juncture.” According to a Times of Israel report, Carmeli
said, “But the economy demands we do more. A lot will depend on what we
see happen in the coming weeks. It will be very difficult emotionally
and socially for all of us if we have to go back to curfew at some
point.” He thought schools should have just ended for kids over 10. “We
were close to the summer break, anyway.” Kids over 10 could be home
alone allowing their parents to go back to work.
The USA’s Center for Disease Control has predicted that opening up
the country would result in a spike in the virus. While they have seen a
downturn in NYC, Texas and Florida have both recorded a sharp increase.
According to reports, Israel is one of the world’s leaders in testing
people. The findings are that young people are the most affected but
have a low mortality rate. Fewer than 5% over 80 are infected. Israel
with 260 or so deaths, has done well compared to countries with a
similar population, like Sweden, with 2,500 deaths, Belgium with 7,500
deaths. The USA has proportionally 300 times the number of deaths as
Israel.
Many early spreaders were young people returning from vacation. The
others were from Purim parties where people who didn’t know they had the
virus infected others.
Experts all agree that masks slow the spread of the virus.
Researchers at Ben Gurion University have discovered that surface
coatings based on nanomaterials they have developed, with both antiviral
and antibacterial properties, can be used to fight the current
coronavirus. The nanomaterial contain nanoparticles of safe metal ions
and polymers, including copper, that can be turned into a liquid and can
be sprayed on surfaces to prevent the virus from adhering. Apparently,
the coronavirus doesn’t like copper.
This new spray, if it proves effective, would be applied to surfaces
in hospitals and ships and schools to prevent the virus from spreading.
Also, according to Ynetnews, Israel has isolated a key coronavirus
antibody at its main biological research laboratory, the defense
minister said on Monday, calling the step a “significant breakthrough”
toward a possible treatment for the COVID-19 pandemic. The “monoclonal
neutralizing antibody” developed at the Israel Institute for Biological
Research (IIBR) “can neutralize it (the disease-causing coronavirus)
inside carriers’ bodies,” outgoing Defense Minister Naftali Bennett said
in a statement.
POLITICS
The High Court has ruled that PM Netanyahu’s is eligibile to run for
PM. The Likud and Blue and White made changes to the coalition agreement
that the court found objectionable. The Knesset ratified the agreement
Thursday.
The swearing in will take place on May 13 as coalition wrangling continues.
Current Defense Minister Bennet is vying for the Health Ministry
since Blue and White’s Gantz will become the new Defense Minister until,
after 18-months, he become Prime Minister in the rotation agreement.
However, it was announced on Thursday that a Health Minister has been
chosen, just not Bennet.
A flurry of criticism has arisen over Netanyahu’s announcement he
will annex 130 settlements in the West Bank according to think tank
scholars David Makovsky and Dennis Ross who wrote in a Times of Israel
opinion piece. The pair say this is Netanyahu last hurrah as a PM, and
knowing that he won’t run again, and wants to become President Netanyahu
can now enforce the Trump peace plan and annex the settlements. Risking
the wrath of Jordan and other moderate Arab states willing to make an
agreement with Israel. Blue and White leader Gantz has said he would
support Netanyahu’s initiative.
On Sunday, for the first time, the number of infections in Israel has
dropped. While over 16,000 have been infected, and over 230 died, the
number of seriously ill has dropped as has the number of people on
respirators. Israel is beginning to emerge from the COVID-19 isolation.
One million school children from first to third grade have returned to school in Israel.
More grades will return by May 15th. Tens of thousands of Palestinian
workers have returned to their jobs in Israel, albeit after having
their temperature taken and given a mask. Grandparents are now allowed
to visit their grandchildren. Beauty parlors and barbershops also
reopened with staff and customers all wearing masks. For the first time
the number of infections has dropped.
The Ministry of Health has approved those openings. That ministry is
at odds with the Ministry of Finance, that has proposed a four-stage
plan to emerge from the lockdown but without specifying dates.
In the Finance Ministry’s first stage, malls and outdoor markets
will open, and Palestinian workers from the West Bank will be allowed to
return to construction jobs in Israel.
For the second stage, group classes and community centers will be
opened, but swimming pools in the centers will remain closed.
Non-medical health treatments, such as physiotherapy, will be allowed,
and nature preserves and museums will reopen, said the report, which did
not cite its sources.
In the next stage, movie theaters, theaters for plays, fitness
centers, essential flights, auditoriums, restaurants and bars will open
for business. Lastly, night clubs, swimming pools, water parks and
amusement parks will be opened to the public.
The Health Ministry wants to wait to see if there is a new wave of
infections before opening up the country any more. The Health Ministry
says the next two weeks will be critical. If more infections arise
because of the loosening of the restrictions, then the restrictions
would be reimposed.
The Israeli public is straining at the leash. According to police
reports more and more people were ignoring the restrictions. On Shabbat,
the parks were busy with people still respecting the social distancing
rules. However, not everyone wore a mask.
In one park on Shabbat, parents allowed their children to play on the
forbidden swings and monkey bars and teeter-tooters. When another a
family of friends came by, the father of the first family called out
laughing, “Look, see our young criminals.”
According to Israel Channel 12 health commentator Dr. Gabi Barabash,
social distancing was more important than the isolation in apartments.
As an aside, he also said that once infected a person could not be
reinfected in the short term. Those who appeared to be reinfected were
probably diagnosed as the result of a test that was taken while they
were ill and the results appeared only after the patient was well.
The Israeli cabinet is still deciding on rules for the behavior
during the epidemic. Later today, the cabinet is slated to approve
outdoor gatherings of up to 20 people, in a decision that will go into
effect immediately, according to the office of Interior Minister Aryeh
Deri. Deri represents the ultra-orthodox Shaas party. Some
ultra-orthodox rabbis have already ignored the regulations and opened up
their Yeshivot. Although they claimed on Israel TV they were enforcing
social distancing and wearing masks, the TV footage did not support the
claim.
.
High Court of Justice Special Session
Meanwhile, the political crisis continues. Yesterday, Israel’s High
Court, sat in an extraordinary televised live session of 11 judges out
of 15. The judges all wore masks and plastic dividers separated them.
The court heard motions to clarify if temporary PM Netanyahu could form a
coalition while under indictment for three felonies. “Netanyahu has
been charged with fraud, breach of trust and accepting bribes in a
series of scandals in which he is accused of offering favors to media
moguls in exchange for favorable press coverage. He denies the
accusations and says he is the victim of a media-orchestrated witch
hunt,” wrote Ynetnews.
Attorney General Mandelblit, who indicted Netanyahu, said he saw no
legal reason why Netanyahu could not serve as Prime Minister. Observers
say the court will be hesitant to interfere with Netanyahu becoming
prime minister since the public elected him and the Knesset was set to
ratify the coalition agreement of 75 Knesset members. The court has been
criticized by Netanyahu’s Likud and others of subverting democracy by
taking the decision who would be prime minister out of the hands of the
people.
According to YnetNews, “Netanyahu and his allies have long considered
the high court a liberal bastion that overreached its boundaries to
meddle in political affairs, accusing it of undermining the will of the
people as expressed in national elections. His opponents regard the
court as the final safeguard of Israeli democracy that has been under
dangerous assault from demagogic populists.”
According to AP, Netanyahu is eager to remain in office throughout
his trial, using his position to lash out at the judicial system and
rally support among his base. The coalition deal also gives him
influence over key judicial appointments, creating a potential conflict
of interest during an appeals process if he is convicted. No one has
forgotten that Netanyahu’s trial is scheduled for the end of May.
However, on Monday, the second day the court sat, the court heard
motions concerning the legality of the coalition agreement between the
Likud and the Blue and White party. The agreement was ostensibly
drafted as an ’emergency government’ because of the COVID-19 epidemic.
But the epidemic appears to be nearing the end. The agreement allows for
delaying appointments, and changing rules, over a six-month period due
to the epidemic, and perhaps extending those rules over three years that
the government is to be in power.
There was an obvious irritation by the court on many of the items in
the coalition agreement, including changes in the Basic Law (Israel’s
version of the constitution. Israel does not have a constitution and the
Basic Law is used instead.) The court appeared concerned that changes
in the basic law to allow the rotation would violate the Basic Law. In
the agreement not only would there be a rotation after 18-months, but
the outgoing Prime Minister, in this case Netanyahu, would still be a
Prime Minister but in a secondary position. How can you have two prime
ministers, the court asks?
Only if the basic law is changed, said analysts.
The deal, and the new law, calls for Netanyahu to serve first as
prime minister and Blue and White’s Gantz as the designated premier,
with the two swapping posts after 18 months. The new position of
‘designated premier’ will enjoy all the trappings of the prime minister,
including an official residence and an exemption from a law that
requires all public officials, except a prime minister, to resign if
charged with a crime. In this case Netanyahu would be exempt from
resigning for 36-months, or so he hopes, said one analyst.
Deputy Chief Meltzer (left) Chief Justice Esther Hayut (right)
The court also questioned Netanyahu’s attorney Rebelo why key
government appointments like Chief of Police had to wait six months or
more as part of the ’emergency government.” Why not appoint these key
positions immediately after the government is formed? Why wait?
Then there was the question asked yesterday what would happen if the
Knesset voted to ban Netanyahu from becoming PM because of the
indictments? “I asked you yesterday for an answer and you didn’t have
it. Do you have it today?” asked deputy chief justice Meltzer.
Netanyahu’s attorney Rabelo tried to get out of the answer, according to
the Channel 11 political analyst, but Meltzer pushed until he got an
answer. ” If that happened, warned Netanyahu’s attorney Rabelo, it
would be illegal and the country would go right to new elections.”
There were other items in the agreement, like the “Norwegian Law”
that allows any MK who is appointed to a cabinet post to resign
temporarily from the Knesset, thereby permitting the next candidate on
the party’s list to enter parliament in their place. The court said that
the public elected one list, and specific people, and it would be
unfair to substitute someone who was not elected.
Chief Justice Esther Hayut ordered Blue and White attorney Bar-On to
provide a legal justification for the law within the next 24 hours.
Bar-On agreed. After that exchange and the court’s lunch break, Blue and
White issued a statement that they were considering cancelling the
request to keep the Norwegian law in the agreement
The court also objected to the bloated cabinet with 36 ministers and four deputy ministers, something not seen before.
When the petitioners rose after the lunch break to present their
case, against the yet-to-be passed legislation sanctioned by the unity
deal, Justice Menachem Mazuz says they’re “irrelevant” to the hearing at
hand.“They are political, moral, public arguments… speeches that don’t
have a connection to the legal level.. and are irrelevant here,” Mazuz
said. The court hinted that it could not rule on the unity government
agreement until all the terms have been finalized and the agreement
ratified by the Knesset. In other words, the court may refrain from
ruling on the agreement at this time.
Most analysts expect the court to rule on the petitions by Thursday,
the day the Knesset is scheduled to adjourn for the summer. Thursday
marks the deadline for presenting a new government before new elections
are called. If the court rules they have no objection to the coalition
agreement until it is ratified, then Netanyahu can go to the Knesset
before it adjourns and form a government.
If the coalition agreement is not ratified by the Knesset before the
summer break then new elections would be called for sometime in
August.The fourth in a year. That would mean, say analysts, that nearly
two years would have passed since Netanyahu called for new elections and
since Israel last had an elected government.
When IKEA, the popular furniture chain, was allowed to reopen in Israel during the COVID-19 crisis, other superstores and small shops who were still shuttered demanded also to open. This brought about an easing of restrictions. Even beauty parlors and barbershops reopened this week. All employees and customers were to maintain social distancing, wear masks, and check for fevers. The pressure then mounted on the government to open the schools and other shops while the indoor malls remained open.
On Monday, the government announced that kindergartens and grades 1-3 in schools would reopen on May 3rd. By May 15th most of the restrictions on the population are expected to be lifted.
HMO's are expected to assume the task of performing the COVID-19 tests. A reporter on Channel 12 TV news asked how were those people who suspected they had the virus but did not have a car were expected to arrive at the HMO? If these people took public transportation and it turned out they were infected they may infect everyone on the bus.
Channel 12 health commentator Dr. Barabash said that the wisdom of opening up the country wouldn't be determined for at least ten days, the incubation period of the virus. Barabash hoped a new wave of the virus wouldn't appear.
As for IKEA, the furniture chain's Israeli franchise is owned by a partnership between Matthew Bronfman, a son of Edgar Bronfman (former CEO of the Seagram's company), and Yacov Shalom Fisher, an Israeli businessman.
Yediot Achranot, the Israeli daily, connected the IKEA
opening to Health Minister Yacov Litzman, a member of the Gur Hassidic movement, the world's largest Hassidic sect. According to that newspaper, Shalom Fisher, as he is called, is a Gur Hassid. Other websites dispute that Fisher is a Gur Hassid, but confirm that IKEA has donated 1.3 million shekels (@$400,000) in recent years to the Gur movement.
According to the blog Ashdod Net, Bronfman and Fisher are the biggest donors to the Gur Hassidic movement. Ashdod net claims that IKEA's controlling shareholders Bronfman and Fisher contributed over 1 million shekels (@$300,000) to the Gur Institutions Association in 2017. Between 2014-2016 IKEA-Israel donated 283,000 shekels(@$80,000) to Gur. The website claims that the Admor, Yaakov Aryeh Alter, the head of the Gur Hassidim, his family and his entourage, spends his annual holidays in Shalom Fisher's home.
According to that website, Litzman's Gur Hassidic movement also received donations from the Tempo soft drink company, Strauss, Tnuva and others. Both Litzman's Health Ministry and IKEA deny any favoritism in allowing IKEA to be one of the first stores to open in Israel. This, when pictures of shoppers at IKEA were lined up waiting to get into the stores, albeit with masks and at a safe distance, and other shops were shuttered.
Yesterday, Yaacov Litzman has resigned from his position as Minister of Health and been given instead Minister of Housing. As Minister of Health Litzman resisted restrictions of large gatherings at weddings and in synagogues until, according to pundits, he realized the error of his ways.
If the reports are true, Litzman was acting under orders from the head of the Gur Hassidic movement, since among the ultra-orthodox, especially Hassidim, the Rebbe of the group gives orders and those who follow these orders ignore them at risk of expulsion from the group or community.
Now, Litzman has been handed the Housing Ministry. Reportedly, he was advised to take this ministry by Interior Minister Aryeh Deri, head of the ultra-orthodox Shas political party. (Deri is a convicted felon who served time in prison for graft and corruption while Interior Minister in a previous government, also run by PM Netanyahu.) With Litzman as Housing Minister contractors within the ultra-orthodox community, analysts say, may receive favorable terms for housing developments. And, say these analysts, the ultra-orthodox community will receive priority when new housing becomes available.
Yesterday, Israel's Ministry of Finance allowed a grant of 6 billion shekels (nearly $2B) to several large chain stores who claimed they should be compensated for the forced closure due to the virus. One of the demands of the businessmen was that the companies should be paid 10,000 shekels (@$3,000) per employee. However, TV news commentators stated that most employees worked at minimum wage or part-time, and only very few received 10,000 shekels a month in salary. The commentators claimed that these businesses were trying to recoup losses they'd suffered not by the COVID-19 but by internet competition that undercut their often high, sometimes outrageously high, prices. Some cynics speculate that these businessmen contribute to PM Netanyahu's Likud party.
Then there is the question of Netanyahu's upcoming trial for three felonies. The trial is to be held on May 27th. However, Attorney General Mandelblit, who brought the indictments, said in the media that he fears that Dan Eldad, the temporary state prosecutor appointed by Netanyahu acolyte Justice Minister Amir Ohana, is trying to ignore the rule of law. Mandelblit claims that Eldad has been subverting Mandelblit. And worse, shortly after taking office, launched an investigation into a company then run by Benny Gantz, coincidently the candidate who was running against Netanyahu for Prime Minister. Mandelblit also said that Justice Minister Ohana is bent on ousting him, perhaps with the help of Netanyahu, and has asked Eldad to reopen an investigation about a case where Mandelblit was under suspicion of misdeeds but was cleared.
The new coalition agreement between Netanyahu's Likud party and Benny Gantz's Blue and White gives Netanyahu veto power over the appointment of a permanent state prosecutor as well as the successor to Mandelblit as attorney general. Likud will also control the committee appointing high court judges. According to reports, this has led Mandelblit to believe that Netanyahu is behind the efforts of Ohana and Eldad to oust him. Netanyahu has been charged with fraud, bribery, and breach of trust. Pundits believe that having influence over the Knesset judicial committee, and the appointment of both the state prosecutor and the attorney general might allow Netanyahu to somehow slip out of the charges against him.
Historian and political commentator Yuval Harari said in a recent op-ed piece in Yediot Achronot that at the outbreak of the COVID-19 epidemic, Netanyahu had tried to stage a coup under the guise of managing the health crisis. "An unelected prime minister...tried to close down parliament and rule by emergency decree without any parliamentary supervision," Harari said. Harari tweeted that his move was turning Israel into a dictatorship.
In an interview with the Times of Israel Harari said the coup failed because there was enough resistance from other parties, the media, and public demonstrations against dissolving parliament. According to Harari, Netanyahu realized he had to make a deal. Had there been no resistance he would have kept on ruling under emergency decree without any parliamentary supervision. "Very often coups try to hide their real nature," said Harari. Tanks in the streets and taking over TV stations are not always necessary.
Where is Benny Gantz in all of this? observers ask. The man who said he would never sit in a government with a thrice indicted prime minister has seemingly turned into a powder puff, say these observers. Netanyahu has control of all the major judicial posts. Gantz is slated to become the Minister of Defense. His Blue and White partner Gabi Ashkenazi will become Foreign Minister.
Former prime minister Ehud Barak has called on Gantz to leave the coalition before it is formalized by the Knesset. According to Barak, Netanyahu will never fulfill promises he made to Gantz. Or the public. Hopefully, said one observer, should Gantz stay with Netanyahu, he will be a better minister of defense, protecting the country, then he was as a candidate for prime minister.
To underline the gravity of the present situation, historian Harari is concerned that not only will the virus return but will return in a mutated version, creating even more havoc worldwide. Given this dour prediction, said a pundit, an honest stable government seems an enviable, if not essential, alternative.
Aspersions are easy
to toss around. According to an article in Huffpost.com, quoting
research by the Washington Post and NBC News, the Dorr
brothers-Chris, Ben, Aaron, and Mathew, have formed the largest
Facebook groups organizing protests around the country. The brothers
have a history of exploiting far-right causes to rake in hundreds of
thousands of dollars. The groups were “Against Excessive
Quarantines” in states like Michigan, Wisconsin, Ohio and
Minnesota.
The groups have over
200,000 members. The Facebook group steer people to websites to
donate money for various right-wing causes, like anti-abortion or
pro-Trump causes. The brothers pocket the money, according to the
news reports.
But the groups
incite far-right and white-supremacist groups to action. An
anti-shutdown rally in Michigan was organized by the Michigan Liberty
Militia, a white nationalist group. They Dorr websites also spur
anti-vaccination extremists to attend or organize anti-shutdown
demonstrations.
So have far-right
organizers like the radical Proud Boys and the Three Percenters have
heeded the call, as seen in San Diego, Tennesse, and New Hampshire.
Another demonstration was held in Idaho by Diego Rodriguez, a pastor
and former Republican candidate for the state senate. Rodriguez recently held an Easter church service with Ammon Bundy, a militia
leader.
The Three Percenters have been implicated in multiple anti-Muslim terror
plots. They coined the code word “boogaloo,” a term used by white
supremacists, militia and far-right circles to describe the bloody
civil war they hope is coming to America.
The infamous cartoon
of Jews as the source of the COVID-19 was pasted on a placard at a
recent anti-shutdown demonstration.
But the aspersions
are not limited to white-supremacist groups. Palestinians have blamed
Israel. According to the New York Times, Chinese agents amplified
messages that sowed panic in the USA, copying Russian tactics. The
messages warned the Trump administration was about to lock down the
entire country. Iran has blamed both Israel and the USA, and Jews in
general for the virus. And in India, Muslims are blamed for causing
the virus.
Meanwhile, the virus
seems to be abating. Israel has begun to ease the restrictions, but
not until the Veterans Day and following Independence Day holidays
have passed next week. Then some schools will reopen as well as more
stores, but not malls and theaters.
In Israel, the virus
spurred Blue and White chief Benny Gantz to join an emergency
coalition with Prime Minister Netanyahu. Gantz was harshly criticized
for the move. His former partners in Blue and White have filed
lawsuits with the High Court against the unity. Should the High Court
disqualify Netanyahu from serving because of the three criminal
indictments against him, then Gantz has agreed to dissolve the
government and go to new elections, the fourth is a little more than
a year.
The economy is
dragging with over one million Israelis unemployed. Former Shin Bet
(Israel’s FBI) head Yuval Diskin has castigated Gantz for forming a
coalition with a “thrice indicted” politician. Diskin said
Netanyahu was only interested in avoiding justice.
As if to underline
this point, Attorney General Mandelblit has come to a verbal duel
with the temporary state prosecutor Eldad, who he accuses of,
essentially, being a lackey of the Likud. Eldad started an
investigation into B&W Benny Gantz for fraud while the election
campaigns were raging. In an unusual move, prosecuting attorneys and
others in the Justice Ministry have complained that Eldad was
unsuited for the position.
Also, the Likud is
angling to control the judiciary committee that will approve new
judges. This, pundits say, is a move by Netanyahu to appoint judges
who will keep him out of prison.
In any case, the
rate of infection seems to have slackened in Israel, with 14, 882
infections, 193 fatalities, and 107 on ventilators. Experts warn there
may be a new outbreak in the winter that will create difficulties
should testing not be in place. Experts say it is essential for the
the virus to be detected in the flu season, something so far difficult to
accomplish. Especially since the IDF’s intelligence division says
the COVID-19 may last until the fall of 2021.
While the Dorr
brothers continue their incitement and radical right-wingers agitate
for no lockdowns, health officials say the virus will be around for a
while and the safest way to avoid illness is to stay indoors,
maintain social distancing, and keep your hands clean. Especially
those who are in the most at-risk sectors.
In Israel, everyone is equal but some more equal than others. As the
lockdown continues the country
is facing a surreal
scene: empty roads, beaches, parks, playgrounds, bike paths, hiking
trails and of course bars and restaurants, theaters and all places of
entertainment including sports halls and gymnasiums. Fines are
imposed for those caught breaking the rules. Or, for most caught
breaking the rules.
Over the Passover
holiday, rules were imposed to restrict family gatherings. While this
the rule created hardship for many, distancing children from their
parents, and grandparents from their grandchildren, cousins from
cousins, siblings from siblings, these rules apparently didn’t apply
to a few of Israel’s leaders.
Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu hosted his son Avner and his girlfriend at the
Passover Seder. His excuse was that his son lived next door. Yisrael Beiteinu leader Avigdor Leiberman hosted his family at his home in the
settlement of Nokdim. Almost as bad as the Prime Minister was
Israel’s President Ruby Rivlin who hosted one of his daughters and
her children for the seder. Immigration Minister Yoav Galant also
flouted the rules and hosted a daughter for the entire seven day
Passover holiday.
Not to mention
President Trump’s daughter Ivanka who flew from her Washington home
to one of her father’s golf resorts in New Jersey for the holiday
with her husband Jared and their children.
Only President
Rivlin apologized, twice, for his ignoring the rules. Rivlin is 80 and recently widowed. Still, no excuse. Israel has many
elderly citizens who are alone.
So far, Israel has
over 12,000 reported cases of COVID-19 and 140 deaths. This makes
Israel #18 in the world of those countries infected. While some think
Israel has acted quickly and effectively to combat the virus, critics
say that the country was caught unprepared just as the country was in the
1973 Yom Kippur war. Then, tank crews called up for reserve duty
jumped in their tanks to find rats and mice and rust with gas masks
unusable or missing.
This time it was the
lack of tests and labs and ventilators. Only in the last few days has
Israel been prepared to begin testing 10,000 people a day. This, when
experts say the key to fighting this COVID-19 is testing and more
testing so those infected could be isolated from the main population.
Still, fears that
the ill would overwhelm the health system have not come to fruition.
Israel expected as many as 4,000 on ventilators, so far the number
hasn’t reached 200.
New York’s
Governor Cuomo has also expressed hope that the worst is over. New
York seems to be one of those places that epitomize unpreparedness.
The NYTimes reports that the city received mixed signals from the
governor and the federal government over how to respond to the
pandemic. The results made the state one of the countries hotspots
and contributed to the USA holding the unenviable title of the most
infected country in the world.
There are those who
blame U.S. President Trump for the disaster claiming he refused to
accept the evidence that the virus was a raging killer. With over
600,000 Americans infected and over 30,000 deaths, President Trump
still seems to ignore reality, according to some observers. Critics
say that Trump badly mishandled this crisis and that bumbling might cost him the
election in the fall.
Meanwhile, in Israel,
no progress has been made in the talks for a national unity
government. Blue and White leader Gantz’s mandate to form a
government ran out at midnight on Wednesday. President Rivlin turned to the Knesset that now has 21 days to come up with a candidate who can form a
majority of 61 Knesset members. If no candidate is found the Knesset must
establish a date for the fourth round of elections.
Observers say that
Netanyahu's talk about forming a national unity government was only a way to stall until his trial date while trying to
get that date postponed or canceled. Now, with no government on the
horizon, and new election probable in the early fall, Netanyahu
remains Prime Minister until the new elections. Critics say that if
he had been serious about a national unity government to fight this
pandemic he would have agreed to the terms Blue and White demanded.
Instead, say these critics, Netanyahu played a cynical game to stay
in power ignoring the best way to fight the epidemic, like turning
over testing to the IDF and his political rival Neftali Bennet.
One of the main
sticking points between Netanyahu and Ganz was Blue and White’s insistence that a law be passed in the Knesset forbidding a Prime
Minister from serving in the office if he was under indictment. Netanyahu
firmly rejected that demand. Now pundits expect him to try to pass a
“French Law” that allows him to stay in office and only face
trial when his term expires.
Time will tell if
Netanyahu’s strategy worked. Meanwhile, the battle against the virus
goes on. And the only certainty when it comes to equality is that
everyone is equal when death knocks at the door. By flaunting the
rules that apply to the common man, those in power may have opened
themselves up to the very problem the isolation was meant to prevent.
At the very least, say the critics, they showed a lack of
responsibility and leadership not to mention a breach of the public's
trust.
Last, money.
Israel has nearly a million people unemployed. This inability to go to
work and earn a living is found around the globe. The pressure is on to open
the gates and let the workforce go back to their jobs. The danger,
warn the experts, is spreading the virus that has been contained
during the period of lockdown and self-quarantine. Some economists
warn that the effects of a continued lockdown will be worse than the
pandemic creating a recession or a depression with calamitous
results. So far the Health Ministry in Israel has prevailed over the
Finance Ministry. How long can that resistance to economic arguments
last?
One of the solutions suggested is that the lockdown will be lifted gradually and those
with the highest immunity released first while those at the highest risk
released last. Since health officials say many children under nine
may be asymptomatic, a quandary arises as to when to reopen schools, a
key factor in allowing parents to return to work. Experts say this
pandemic is new and brings fresh problems never faced before. But,
say some observers, plans should have been drawn up to account for
these problems and prepare for an orderly “exit.” So far, there
is no consensus, at least in Israel, how to proceed safely.
What you didn’t know about “quarantine.” According to an
an exhibit entitled “plague” at the Museum of Archeology in Herne,
Germany, (https://www.youtube.com/user/LWLLandesmuseumHerne/videos
) In 1377, in the Venetian port of Ragusa (today Dubrovnik) the
first specially designated isolated areas was introduced for sailors,
passengers and goods coming from supposedly plague-contaminated
areas.
These people and
shipments were kept in isolation for quaranta (forty
inItalian),
40 days. Quarantine, the name we use today, is derived from that
Italian word. The exhibit also talks about Christian communities
which pledged to build churches should the plague spare their towns
and villages.
That plague was not
terribly merciful. Within seven years the Black Plague caused the
death of 25 million people. A third of the European population at
that time. Not until the turn of the 20th century did a
scientist named Vladimir Haffkine develop a vaccine for the bubonic
plague (Black Plague). He first tested the virus on himself. (See
previous Jerusalem Magazine post or that on our Facebook page.)
Today, labs around
the world are frantically seeking a vaccine to prevent the COVID-19,
or a cure for the disease. With nearly two million people infected
worldwide, and over 100,000 deaths, the race is on.
A team at Oxford
University in Britain, lead by Prof. Sarah Gilbert, has encouraging
results. “We are 80% confident our vaccine will work,” said Prof.
Gilbert,who expects the vaccine to be ready for human trials in two
weeks. “This is not a hunch,” said the professor.
A company in the
USA, Moderna, is already conducting clinical trials for a vaccine.
Another company in
the USA, Gilead, has been successfully using an Ebola drug called
remdesevir and seen improvement in 36 patients over several weeks. In
Israel the Migdal Galilee Research Institute has said their vaccine would be ready for testing in a few weeks. Another Israeli company,
Pluristem, has treated 7 COVID-19 patients with its PLX cells. All
the patients were on ventilators and suffering acute respiratory
failure and inflammatory complications from the coronavirus. So far
three have been weaned from the ventilators. Four of the seven show
signs of improvement. Usually, over 80% of those on ventilators never
recover.
Another hopeful sign
comes from the company Inovio, based in Pennsylvania. Inovio is
packaging a section of the Conovirus’ genetic code inside a piece
of synthetic DNA, then those cells are injected into the patient as a
vaccine. These cells produce a harmless protein that make protective
immune anti-bodies that lay in wait for a real coronavirus. Kate
Broderick, Inovio R&D chief said, “it's like giving the body an
FBI wanted poster so it can recognize the enemy.” And then destroy
it.
Meanwhile, the
plague has not abated. A recent study showed that commuters in New
York City is still standing shoulder to shoulder on the subways. NYC
has cut down the frequency of the trains but apparently that only
meant more people were stuffed together in whatever cars arrived.
Some analysts say that with New York the epicenter of the virus in
the USA a more aggressive approach should be used.
One pundit said that
as US President Donald Trump is now criticized for his making light
of the dangers of the virus, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who
once agreed with Pres. Trump, may have seen the error of his ways.
Johnson admitted he was near death after contracting the virus and
profusely thanked the staff of St. Thomas's hospital in London for
saving his life. The British government had downplayed the extent of
his illness.
Greece has turned
out to be a leader in the pandemic fight, according to Takis Pappas,
a political scientist at Helsinki University. Pappas said that Greek
Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis closed down non-essential shops
four days after the first case of the virus appeared, while Italy
(pop. 60 million, 152,271 infected, 19,468 deaths) waited 18 days
and Spain (pop. 47 million, 163,027 infected, 16,972 deaths) 30
days. In Greece, social distancing and the quarantine seem to be the
most effective methods so far to contain the spread of the virus.
Greece (pop. 10 million) has had only 2,081 cases of infection and 93
deaths.
Certain population
groups seem harder hit than others. In Chicago, Black Americans
account for more than 50% of those infected. In Illinois, 43% of the
deaths are Black Americans.
In Israel, (pop. @9
million, 10,743 infected, 103 deaths) nearly half of the deaths are
from the Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) community. Israel has over 10,000
cases of infection. More than a quarter of the deaths are in
Jerusalem, where 75% of those infected are from Haredi neighborhoods.
There are over one million ultra-Orthodox citizens in Israel. Haredi
women have an average of 7.1 children per household, according to a
study by the Israel Democracy Institute. To exacerbate the COVID-19
situation, a recent study showed that one-third of the children in
Israel under 9 years old was asymptomatic, carriers of the virus
without symptoms of illness. Overcrowding at home and in the
community spreads the virus. In the past decade, the percentage of
ultra-Orthodox students grew by 141% compared to the general
population. 114,000 ultra-Orthodox men attended yeshivas (religious
seminaries for bachelors and married) in 2017.
Religious
communities in Israel have banned public gatherings or limited them
to 10 people in certain circumstances. In the Christian communities,
even Easter Sunday was a fizzle compared to the usual elaborate
festivities. The Church of the Holy Sepulchre was closed for the
first time since 1349 during the Black Plague. On a normal Easter
Sunday many thousands would appear for prayers.
Lockdowns were enacted in ultra-Orthodox towns to stop the spread of the virus. 15
neighborhoods in Jerusalem, where 75% of those infected were
ultra-Orthodox, were sealed off. Some Jerusalem residents received
text messages they were restricted to their neighborhoods. No one was
allowed to leave their neighborhood unless to go shopping or to work
or some essential task. Similar restrictions were imposed on other
ultra-Orthodox towns around the country.
On Channel 12 news,
video footage showed police raiding a synagogue in Mea Sharim where a
large number of men had gathered and arrested two men. Each was fined
1,500 shekels. In Tel Aviv residents were to stay within 100 meters
of their homes. Police gave out hundreds of fines to those breaking
the rules.
As NY State (pop.
19.5 million, 181,144 infected, 8,627 deaths) has the unfortunate
lead as the most heavily infected place anywhere in the world, there
is room for optimism. Dr. Marc Lipsitch, a Harvard epidemiologist
said, in an interview on USA Today that there may be more infections
than we think. And that most may be protected by their immune
response. “So, we’re closer to a herd immunity than we think.”
He urges caution in the push to go back to work. “There are things
we don’t know and things we haven’t tested in those kinds of back
to work approaches.” He stresses that a combination of
interventions be put in place that will they may suppress the economy
they still don’t blunt the impact enough on our health care
system.” He said the main push was the need for social distancing
and testing. He stressed that, in order to build a complete data
base to plan stategies for the battle, “ Testing is the key.”
On the Israeli
political front: Blue and White chairman Gantz was denied an
extension to form a coalition. President Rivlin has tasked the
Knesset to chose a PM or call a fourth round of elections.
When the Hebrews
were camped in the desert, after fleeing from Pharaoh's chariots,
they ate unleavened bread. Imagine, if you will, approximately 2
million people, men, women, children, plus livestock, and how far the
camp must have stretched across the sand. Probably as far as Herzliya
to Ashdod, the sea to Ramla. Quite a swath of land. Quite a
concentration of people. Stuffed together. Breathing on each other.
No internet. No telephones. No newspapers. No radio. Regulations and
requests were passed, probably, by word of mouth. A messenger on a
horse, mule, ox, rode from tribe to tribe with the news.
In the Haredi
neighborhoods around the world not much has changed. Over-crowded.
Cut off from the world. Locked into their own deep but narrow tribal
structures. This, in an age when five people sharing a ski gondola
riding up the mountain in Sun Valley, Idaho can get infected by a
visitor from Seattle, Washington. The next morning Washington state
confirmed 102 cases and its 16th death.
Like the Mammoth
Mountain Ski Area in Mono County, California which, according to the
New Yorker Magazine, quoting the Adventure Journal, now has the
highest per-capita rate of COVID-19 in the state. And in Europe,
governments tracked hundreds of coronavirus cases to one Austrian ski
resort.
The fact that the
Jewish community in Britain has so far lost 115 people, about 2% of
all those who have perished so far in Britain, while making up only
about .3% of the population is not surprising considering that the
British government was slow to institute social distancing. The
Jewish communities around the world, like those in Britain, are
usually as packed together as those five passengers on a ski gondola.
Britain’s Prime
Minister Boris Johnson, like US President Donald Trump, and the
Haredi population ignored the warnings of the COVID-19’s dangers.
Johnson’s folly caught up to him, said one pundit. He was diagnosed
with the virus and has become increasingly ill. So far PM Johnson is
not on a ventilator. According to Israel TV’s foreign affairs
commentator Yoav Vardi, 85% of those put on a ventilator does not
survive the virus.
Like the tribes in
the desert, said one analyst, Haredi communities live in a bubble.
Communication is primitive. Posters on walls and along the streets
are the common form of transmitting the information. Or the occasional
visitor, like the messengers on the horse in the desert, bringing
news. Haredi en concentrate on learning tractates of the Talmud and
commentaries, buried in their books, or thinking about the writings
when walking down the street, nearly oblivious to the outside world.
Their wives concentrate on having babies, raising children, cooking
and cleaning, unless, lately they’re sent out to earn money in
hi-tech in a room with other women all on a computer while their
husbands sit and “learn.”
By the time the
warnings broke through their mental barriers and into their homes the
damage was done. This was because the messengers didn’t come from
inside the community, but from the dangerous outside that has always
been critical of the ultra-orthodox and always trying to wrest them
away from their books and insular way of life. Bring them into the
“Godless” Western world.
Observers say, these
people believe deeply that their way of life has been responsible for
keeping the Jewish people together for thousands of years. But that
they have built a fence not only around the Torah but around
themselves,
Some pundits blame
the Haredi leadership for not telling their followers how dangerous
the virus was. But others point out that those leaders had the same mindset as their followers. Specifically, that outsiders were not to
be trusted. Once the followers, and some of the leaders, began
exiting the community on stretchers, the reality began to sink in. By
then it was almost too late.
The Israel Defense
Ministry issued a report stating that one-third of all virus cases in
Israel centered either in Bnei Brak or Jerusalem. ZAKA, the
emergency medical response organization geared to the Haredi
population said the ultra-orthodox were completely confused by the
virus and were looking for leadership.
Some Israelis
pointed the blame at the Minister of Health, Yaacov Litzman, a Gerer
Hassid, who refused for too long to support self-distancing and
quarantines and closing yeshivot and religious schools. He reportedly
flaunted the rules and went to a synagogue for Shabat services. He
paid the price, too. Recently, it was announced that he was infected,
in quarantine, but in good condition.
An opinion piece in
the Times of Israel said that this pandemic might bring a change in
the way Haredi sees the world and produces more independent thought.
Other analysts thought this wishful thinking.
In the Haredi city
of Benei Brak, 38% of the population was infected before the leaders
stepped in, put up notices and posters urging the people to keep
their distance. Still, many ignored the directive. Continued to
gather in study halls and synagogues. The police came in and broke up
the gatherings issuing fines up to $1,500. Skeptics said the fines
would never be paid. Those who wanted to gather were like water
finding a way to seep in between the cracks.
So, more people got
sick. Ramat Gan, the town bordering Benai Brak, put up a fence at
cross streets to keep Benei Brak’s residents from coming into Ramat
Gan and infecting people there. The city of Benei Brak took the case
to the High Court and the fences came down. Reluctantly, say
observers. And not completely. So far in Israel, there have been 60
deaths from the virus with over 9,000 infections. 109 people are on
life support due to the virus.
Yet, in Modiin
Illit, a Haredi town with a population of 73,000, and 151 infected, a
brawl took place when hard-line residents refused to obey Health
Ministry pandemic rules. According to Channel 12 news, while protestors yelled “Help, Judaism is in danger,” and urged others
to ignore the social distancing rules including a ban on public
gatherings, other residents assaulted and chased them. The Kan TV
network said two prayer services, each with 15 people, were broken up
by the police. One of the parishioners told a reporter he does not
recognize the State of Israel nor its regulations. The groups were
part of the hard-line Jerusalem Faction that protests the draft of
ultra-orthodox men into the Israeli army.
Officials fear that
family gatherings for the Passover seder would result in another
outbreak of the virus as happened during the Purim festival. Because
it was mainly the Haredi towns and neighborhoods that were the most
infected in the country, the government proposed to shut down 8
Haredi cities and 15 Jerusalem neighborhoods to stop the spread of
the virus. Reportedly, Haredi Health minister Aryeh Deri and Health
Minister Yaacov Litzman objected, playing to their constituency with
both claiming the government was discriminating against the Haredi
population. Both deny the claim.
Last night, a
a compromise was reached that will not include the Arab population who does not celebrate the Passover holiday. On Tuesday, the Israeli
cabinet approved closure and curfew over the Passover holiday to
stem the spread of COVID-19. The cabinet issued a ban on all
intercity traffic from 19:00 on Tuesday until 06:00 on Friday.
Supermarkets, food deliveries, and essential services will operate
only until 15:00 on Wednesday, but will resume Friday morning.
During the lockdown,
Israelis will be allowed to only go 100 meters from their homes. All
businesses will be shut. Jerusalem residents will be confined to
their neighborhoods, especially those in the northern part of the
city that has the largest number of virus cases. Public
transportation will cease from 20:00 Tuesday until Sunday morning.
All international flights will also be canceled during that period
unless granted special permission by the government. As of Sunday at
07:00, face masks will be mandatory outside the home
One analyst said,
‘This will be a Passover for the history books, said one pundit.
Except there was no parting of the Red Sea. Just a plague.’
Prime Minister Netanyahu believes the left is out to get him at any cost. According to reports, a close friend of Netanyahu has said that the Prime Minister believes there is a conspiracy of what he calls the Deep State to oust him from power. This close confident, unnamed in the report, said that Netanyahu has now succeeded in destroying his opposition, dismantling the Blue and White party, and postponed his trial, perhaps until early winter. Now that Blue and White has been broken apart Netanyahu may opt for another round of elections, the 4th, knowing he faces no real opposition. He may then be able to have the Knesset drop the charges against him. Should he not do that, and become deputy-prime minister, he may still be immune from prosecution. Some say Netanyahu is pondering a run for the Presidency, a position that also carries with it immunity from prosecution, although pundits believe the High Court will prohibit him from escaping justice through these means. His close associate said that Netanyahu will use every means at his disposal to avoid jail and stay in power.
Meanwhile, Health Minister Yaacov Litzman has been diagnosed with COVID-19 causing him and much of Israeli's cabinet to go into quarantine. Litzman never told anyone he may have been ill. Yair Lapid's Yesh Atid party, once part of Blue and White, along with Meretz have demanded Litzman resign from the Health Ministry. They claim Litzman never took the virus seriously as evidenced by the fact that he continued to go to community prayers near his house in violation of the regulations. Infecting others along the way.
So far, Israel has over 7,000 infected with 39 deaths. The government is
now focusing on the ultra-orthodox town of Benei Brak, pop @200,000, on
the outskirts of Tel Aviv. Nearly 40 % of the population of Benei Brak
have been infected. The police, with the help of the army, have closed
off the town to incoming and outgoing traffic. 4,500 elderly residents
are to be evacuated to hotel-type facilities outside the town where they
are to be isolated.
“In Israel there’s not a democracy, but a deep state,’ PM said to claim
“In Israel there’s not a democracy, but a deep state,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has told confidants in recent months, according to a Haaretz report
The remarks have been made by the premier in the context of his upcoming trial in three corruption cases. Netanyahu is reportedly convinced that the justice system is intent on bringing him down.
“They want to see me sitting in jail,” Haaretz quotes the prime minister as having said of officials in the justice system.
Back in the middle-ages Jews survived the black plague, that killed
almost a third of the European continent’s population, and estimated
75-200 million people in Eurasia. But not the Jews. Because of their adherence to hygiene while many of their neighbors, whose hygiene was pitiful, fell to the epidemic, the Jews survived. Hand washing, before eating, after the toilet, upon rising from bed, was a Jewish thing dictated by the rabbis. The result was pogroms across Europe as the Jews were blamed for causing the plague by witchcraft or well-poisoning. By
1351 there had been 350 incidents of anti-Jewish pogroms and 60 major and 150 minor Jewish communities had been exterminated. (The surviving
Jews migrated eastward to Poland and Lithuania.)
Back in the 1930s and 1940s, two famous Catholic priests incited their congregants with anti-Semitic rants. One in the USA and one in
Poland. The former, Father Charles Coughlin, a Canadian-American Roman
Catholic priest based near Detroit, known as the ‘radio priest,’ used his weekly radio program to roil his listeners to near apoplexy. One of the most influential men in the US at the time, he also had his own newspaper espousing the same anti-Semitic, anti-Communist and isolationist views. His audience reached millions and was a key factor
in FDR’s reluctance to join the British in their fight against Nazi
Germany. He was forced off the air in 1939 because of his pro-fascist
and anti-Semitic rants. The Japanese, military allies of the Nazis,
broke FDR’s resolve when they bombed Pearl Harbor leaving the beleaguered president no choice but to go to war.
The second was Cardinal August Hlond, Archbishop of Gniezno and
Warsaw in 1946. The war was over. Poland was in chaos. Armed militias roamed the countryside. In a 1936 pastoral letter, Cardinal August Hlond called Jewish people ‘the vanguard of godlessness, Bolshevism, and subversion,’ but also prohibited attacks on Jews. After the war, The Soviet Union was moving into Poland and many of the newly installed government officials were Jewish communists. Cardinal Hlond was virulently opposed to godless communism as were some of the largest armed militias. The result was the Kielce Massacre where over 40 Jews were murdered in a “pogrom” on July 4, 1946, by a mob and nearly a
hundred injured. Hlond never addressed the pogrom. (https://vimeo.com/ondemand/rescuetraineng)
That pogrom and others sent Jews who had survived the Holocaust fleeing Poland for to the West, many to Israel.(https://vimeo.com/ondemand/tomanheroorthief)
Last Wednesday, according to the Time of Israel, Rick Wiles, the
anti-Semitic Florida pastor who previously said that the effort to
impeach US President Trump was a “Jew coup,” and would “kill millions of
Christians” went on his TruNews website and blamed the spread of coronavirus in synagogues as a punishment of the Jewish people for opposing Jesus.
Sounding like Father Coughlin, Pastor Wiles said, “The people who are going into the synagogue are coming out of the synagogue with the virus,” Wiles said. “It’s spreading in Israel through the synagogues.
God is spreading it in your synagogues! You are under judgment because you oppose his son, Jesus Christ. That is why you have a plague in your synagogues. Repent and believe on the name of Jesus Christ, and the
plague will stop.” He also mistakenly claimed the CODVID-19 started at the AIPAC conference in early March even though the first outbreaks were in Washington state.
In New Jersey, according to the JTA, “A New Jersey man sent Facebook
messages to Gov. Phil Murphy and others threatening to harm Orthodox
Jews for violating state coronavirus restrictions.” The man, Anthony
Lodespoto, 43, or Howell, NJ, was charged with making “terrorist threats
during a state of emergency.” He allegedly used “Facebook’s direct messaging feature to threaten the Jewish community of Lakewood,” saying he would take a baseball bat and punish the offenders. Lakewood, an
ultra-orthodox enclave, like New York Cities Borough Park and
neighboring Crown Heights has seen a sharp rise of confirmed CODVID-19
cases.
Blaming Jews, as we see, is nothing new. Neither are pogroms. Nor massacres. Admiral Dr. Anne Schuchat, who is Jewish, (and consulted on
“Contagion” with Debra Winger and Matt Damon) is deputy director of the
CDC (Center for Disease Control). She said in an interview that people
should fear “the virus” not “the foreign.” She said, “It’s important in the pandemic to avoid stigmatizing any one group — travelers,
immigrants, some populations in our community, anyone in this situation.
The virus does not discriminate. We need to work together to tackle
it.”
But there is some basis to the claims that Jews are spreading the virus, at least in Israel. (nearly 4,500 infected, 15 deaths, nearly 80
serious cases.) Ultra-Orthodox Jews in Israel have been flagrantly
ignoring the requests for self-quarantine, small group gatherings
limited to no more than ten, and keeping a two-meter distance one from
the other.
According to an Israel TV report, nearly half of those hospitalized in Israel with the virus are ultra-orthodox. When the leaders of the
the ultra-orthodox community were first approached by the Israeli government
to tell their followers to follow the Ministry of Health’s rules, they
waved away the advice. “God will protect us if we learn Torah,” said the
Goan HaDor (Genius of the generation) Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, a leader
of the Lithuanian Haredi (ultra-orthodox) community.
Today, however, the hard-line Eda Haredit told their ultra-orthodox
followers to follow the health ministry’s rules or commit a ‘big sin.’
The notice was published as a poster since the ultra-orthodox supposedly have no tv, do not listen to the radio, have no internet and have limited access to apps on their mobile phones. News is word-of-mouth or posters
on the wall.
“New York City’s orthodox communities are at the center of the outbreak (13% of all confirmed cases) with thousands of cases reported and a growing number of deaths,” according to Ynetnews.com. “Almost
every Haredi home has a least one family member sick with the virus.”
Many communities have ignored rules to self-distance. A disproportionate number of orthodox Jews are infected in Great Britain. (5% of
fatalities but only 0.3% of British citizens.) The majority of orthodox
Jews in Strasbourg are reportedly ill while in Belgium, with a large
Haredi population, 85% are expected to contract the disease with 17,000
requiring hospitalization, 550 to perish.
USA’s official medical expert Dr. Anthony Fauci stated the mortality rate in the USA might reach between 200,000-300,000. Pundits speculate
that it is only a matter of time before anti-Semitic rants become more
prevalent.
The great depression, and Hitler’s solution to Germany’s problem, at least expel the Jews, brought Father Coughlin to a vast audience. One
only hopes that in these trying times the Jewish people are not made a
scapegoat once again for the ills of the pandemic. If the economy
teeters and falls, one analyst said, there’s no telling who is going to
take the blame. It won’t be the first time, said another analyst, that
Jews were blamed, persecuted, and eventually expelled, citing as far
back as Babylon, the dispersion after the destruction of the Second
Temple, the Crusades, the Inquisition, the pogroms in England in
1190,(150 killed) the pogroms during the black plague, all the way up to
the Nazis, and beyond. A long history with dark chapters.
The solution is to forestall the spread of the virus, find a cure,
and a vaccine. Jews are usually at the forefront of these discoveries.
What we need is another Dr. Waldemar Mordecai Haffkine, a Jewish scientist, who discovered the vaccine for both cholera and the bubonic plague. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=268U0Odzcsg.
In the feature film “Contagion” it was Dr. Ian Sussman (Elliot Gould)
who bucked bureaucracy and found the vaccine to stop the pandemic.
Let’s hope another Sussman or Haffkine shows up, soon.
Once this crisis if over, said an observer, things will go back to normal.
Israel’s infection
number has passed 3,000, with 13 deaths. (Israel’s Pop. @9
million). Not bad considering a country like Switzerland, Pop. 8.5
million, that has over 12,000 infected and 500 dead. Or the
Netherlands, Pop. 17 million with 8,600 infected and over 1,100
deaths. Belgium, Pop @11 million with 7,284 infected and 1,049
deaths. Or New York City Pop. 8.6 million with 23,000 cases, 365
deaths.
As the guy falling
for the top of the Empire State Building told a secretary who had her
head out the window and asked him how he was doing and he answered,
as we all know, “So far so good.”
Personally, I like
the old-time comedian Heni Youngman’s schtick. “How’re you
doing?” someone asked him. “Better,” he answered. “Better?”
the questioner asked. “Yeah, better you shouldn’t ask.”
Israel is gearing up
to meet the challenge of the virus. Reportedly, the Mossad has
secured 100,000 testing kits. Israel is scouring the markets to buy
more inhalation machines. If the infection rate continues to climb,
say, experts, physicians may have to choose which patient gets the
oxygen and which doesn’t, and dies. Not a pleasant choice. One
Israel is trying to avoid.
So far, with a world
population of 7.8 billion, the world total of those infected has
climbed to over half-a-million and the end is not yet near. According
to the data, 191 out of 195 countries have been infected.
However, total
deaths, 22,000 deaths so far worldwide, are only a fraction of
those who perished in the Spanish Influence of 1918 (Jan 1918 –
Dec 1920) where half a billion people were reportedly infected and 10
percent, approximately 50 million, died of the virus.
Today, according to
Johns Hopkins University date, “The current global mortality rate
now stands at around 4.5%.” Also, according to the World Health
Organization, “A variety of factors affects the mortality rate:
geography, the quality of health care, age of the population, lifestyle and underlying conditions. In China, the mortality rate for
CV-19has been 4%. In Italy, it’s about 10%.
In Iran, it’s about 7.6%. In Germany, it’s less than 1% and in
the U.S., where the outbreak is just getting underway, it’s about
1.5%.
"The mortality rate generally drops as testing rises and more
patients are identified. But epidemiologists caution that the reverse
can be true as U.S. hospitals get inundated and run out of
necessary equipment, like ventilators, to treat patients who might
have otherwise been saved. They also say it takes weeks for the virus
to infiltrate a community and several more before people are sick
enough to die. So it will be several months before the true mortality
rate can be quantified in the U.S. or elsewhere.”
According to the
WHO, “Many scientists think, or are at least hopeful, that the
mortality rate will fall as more people are tested and mild cases
that have previously gone undetected are identified.”
In Israel pundits
have said that the Israeli defense forces should take over the
management of the virus.
The ministry of defense has the manpower and technical resources at its disposal that do
not exist in the private sector. For that reason alone the proposed
appointment of former chief-of-staff Gen (res.) Benny Gantz is a wise
choice, say the observers. The ministry of defense has been likened
to an old-boys network. An outsider has to struggle to get things
done. Gantz, once the star of the army, has an inside track. Coupled
with another former chief-of-staff, Gabi Ashkenazi, who is slated to
become Foreign Minister, consolidating the considerable resources of
the defense establishment should be manageable.
Gantz has run into
both criticism and praise for his move to join Netanyahu. Gantz said
that in this time of crises a national unity government was
imperative and he was not going to stand in the way of fighting the war
against the virus based on personal considerations. Some analysts
laud him for this path. Others say that he was just looking for a way
to become Prime Minister, (he would take that position after
18-months in a rotation agreement). Others say that by alienating his Blue and White partners Lapid and Ya'alon, who now become part of the opposition, Netanyahu will be hard put to pass any legislation in the Knesset. (Gantz says that's why he became Speaker, to get bills assigned to a committee and passed quickly.)
Whatever the
reasons, a national unity government will soon be established,
assuming Gantz and Netanyahu reach terms, which seems likely, and the
business of government could carry on. A budget could be prepared and
passed. Resources could be tapped to fight the plague, and the
country could unify in the war.
Gantz is to become
Minister of Defence, after he gives up his temporary role as Speaker of the Knesset, and Ashkenazi Foreign Minister. Gantz’s scaled-down party, the group left after the disintegration of Blue and
White, will garner approximately 11 ministerial seats. Avraham
Rabinovitch, political commentator for Channel 12, thought this a
bloated and inordinately expensive government that would have over 30
cabinet posts. He also didn’t think Gantz would fare any better
than others who trusted Netanyahu. Men like Avigdor Leiberman, and
Moshe ‘Bougie’ Ayalon who were cast out by Netanyahu and became
his fierce enemies.
However, Gantz also
gets the Justice Ministry and has sworn that democracy will be
protected. His proposed Justice Minister, Chili Trooper, said on
Israel TV last night that there would be no French Law passed,
referring to the law passed in the French parliament to ensure that
indicted PM Jacques Chiraq would not be prosecuted until he finished
his term in office.
Should Gantz really
be a patriot and have the countries best interests at heart, or was
he out for himself.
Time will tell. If
he becomes the general leading the war against the virus and succeeds
in keeping that plague from overrunning Israel, he will have
justified his dismembering Blue and White. If not?
He’ll be tossed
out by Netanyahu like others before him. And the country will still
be faced with a pandemic managed by amateurs.
“
Thursday, March 26, 2020
UPDATE: GANZ JOINS NETANYAHU
Blue and white party splitting up.
Benny Ganz joined a national unity government with Netanyahu.
He will first run for Speaker of the Knesset instead of Yair Lapid's suggested
candidate. Ganz will then become the Foreign Minister for 18-months and then become Prime Minister in a rotation agreement.
Moshe Yaalon has announced he is leaving Blue and White along with Lapid. Both will join the opposition. Pundits point out that Ganz is worried about the country during the crises and is willing to compromise for the good of the country. Analysts point out that Blue and White really had no chance to take the reins of the government. The coalition was too narrow, mixing Arab parties with
right-wing politicians like Avigdor Leiberman. One analyst said on Israel Radio that Ganz checked the foundations of his building and realized it wouldn't stand in even a mild storm.